Originally Posted by
canid
For sure. The goal isn't to 'collect' food here. It will eventually spoil and you could have a very large collection of spoiled canned goods.
It comes back again to what you regularly like to eat. 3 gallons of black pepper might be a heck of a lot while it's fresh. if you don't open it for 10 years, it could possibly be stale and bland enough to eat it on it's own. In my household we go through about 1lb of it per year, which is as long as it keeps much kick. On the other hand, I personally eat far greater amounts of dried hot chilies, and so those are what I would store.
Salt is important. You can live without pepper, chilies, basil, cilantro, cinnamon and such, but you will die if you do not regularly eat salt. It's pretty cool that it happens to be dirt cheap (though probably not getting any cheaper, it having doubled in price here in 5 years) and it will keep for centuries longer than the buckets you have.
Another thing I like to store, and which must be rotated is dried greens. they don't hold a candle to fresh, but they go well in a lot of things and I invariably end up growing and often end up collecting more than I will use right off. I'm sure you've noticed you live in an area with enough field mustard to make it the bulk of one's diet. Lots of wild fennel too. You get them bone dry and then pack in cans or buckets with dried grains and legumes and they'll keep easily. When you're ready to eat them that way they are already the backbone of a soup.