So do your eyes.Quote:
Originally Posted by samfranklin
Printable View
So do your eyes.Quote:
Originally Posted by samfranklin
For some items Sam, it boils down to how effective they are. While a signal whistle and signal mirror may not have other uses, they are light, take up very little room, and may save your life. How well to you think that charred piece of tin foil will do for signaling? It was marginal at best before you put it in a fire, but almost useless for signaling after you did so. When it comes to safety - you may want to rethink that just a bit.Quote:
Originally Posted by samfranklin
See what I am seeing nearly every item in my tin is multi use I don't know what you think?
fair point crashdive123.
Thanks for the tip but my tin is also polished for signalling and also can be used for boiling food!
Sam - in your first post about your kit, the last line of the post said:We have, do what you will with the feedback that you have received.Quote:
And that is that email with anything you think i should have!
Most items can be multi-use, Sam. All you have to do is learn about your equipment. Some essentials have only one use, and that's because they do their intended job better than other options. Why do you carry matches? Because you can use one as a toothpick?
Getting back to boiling water, what do you do - dump out your kit everytime you need water? What do you store your water in? Remember, it's good to carry a supply - you may not be able to reach water when you need it.
Sam - have you used tin foil to boil water? As you say, it does work, and it is great to have that option in order to get yourself through a tough spot. The foil will deteriorate and weaken though when exposed to fire. I have boiled water in foil as a field test. After the boiling, the foil may have been able to boil a second batch of water, but that was about it. After using it, it was pretty much useless. You may want to add a metal canteen cup to your kit.
Sam, would you mind telling us a bit about yourself? Age, training, real experience? Our advice is much better when we know your skill level.
Okay, as far as grades go you get a "C-" in Survival "101". You also lost points in debating the experts, you have no justification in doing so. You need to PAY ATTENTION; the info here can save your life. I'm not sure if you're trying to sound like a "know-it-all" or not, but that's how you're coming across. Add the whistle & the mirror. Based on your posts so far I can see that your survival kit lacks it's most important element. Your challenge now is to tell me what it is. NOBODY HELP! He needs to learn!:cool2:
Yes SIR, Sarge! http://www.freesmileys.org/smileys/s...ansport032.gifQuote:
Originally Posted by Sarge47
Crashdive123,
Sorry you mistook me i meant to use the tin for boiling water.
Sarge 47 I am listening to their advice and I think to be fair all I am doing is arguing my survival kit to be useful and that I can perfectly justify that.
Ken
I do not want to disclose my age over the internet so I am afraid I won't do that but,
I have been on training courses with SERE and I have been given advice from NAVY SERE INSTRUCTORS who said my survival kit was excellent. I have slept 4 nights on bodmin moor only using my survival kit and have survived so. I thank you all for your comments
Hmmmm. What is Sarge talking about? :innocent:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sarge47
Okay, Sam, let's play this a different way, okay?
Let's start with a few questions:
What type of physical environment are we talking about?
What are the possible weather conditions?
What season of the year is it?
Do you know your wild edibles in the area?
Do you have hunting experience with small and/or large game indigenous to the area?
What is your physical condition? Any medical issues?
Stand by for the next hundred questions...........
Physical Enviroment: Moors with woodland areas
Possible weather conditions: Rain anything less than hail really
Season: Any time when sunny rainy really (I build shelters out of all natrual materials)
Edibles: Yes and my survival rations can las t me up to ten days
Hunting: With the rabbits yes
Pysical: None this is in a permissive enviroment
thanks
You said:
The Rations listed in your kit are:Quote:
Originally Posted by samfranklin
You plan on losing some weight?Quote:
Originally Posted by samfranklin
Bare in mind the body can last 3 weeks without food.
Ahhh. You allude to the Rule of 3's. And the rest are????Quote:
Originally Posted by samfranklin
One i don't understand your comment,
And sorry you missed out my porrigde food bar.
Sam, I have also ventured into the woods once or twice. :innocent: I take a kit and rations with me. Have I always relied on my rations? Well, except for the coffee, the answer for several of my ventures is "no," and even at such times I'd often gain a few pounds in a week.Quote:
Originally Posted by samfranklin
I assume your posts to be true, and, from what you have written, I suspect that you are at the novice skill level. Am I correct?
Sorry about missing the porridge bar. How many calories is that?Quote:
Originally Posted by samfranklin
The Rule of 3's? Didn't learn that in SERE?
the calories I am not sure about
I am a bit above novice level i think.
Sam, I commend you for acknowledging that you are around or just above the novice level. We all were at one time.Quote:
Originally Posted by samfranklin
First, read the threads of interest to you posted in the Forums.
Second, use the Search feature in the Forum taskbar for specific information/questions. You'll be AMAZED at the information posted here.
Third, if you have a question, just ask. The chances are that several members will have the knowledge and experience to answer specific questions. When asking a question, be as specific as you can be. Include information in your question whenever possible.
Fourth, don't presume that you understand how something works simply because you've read about it or have had a question answered. You must have practical hands-on boots-in-the-field experience to truly understand many of the things discussed here.
Fifth, again, welcome to the Forum, Sam!
Sam, I appreciate you asking the questions that you are asking. While it is true that the rule of 3's state that you can survive for 21 days without food, that assumes minimal physical activity. If you are building shelter, hunting, hiking your way out - you will need food long before 21 days.
Multi use items are excellent but don't get quite so wrapped in it. Some items, while only serving a single purpose, do it so well that they require a place in your kit. The Starflash mirror that Ken posted is one of those. so is a whistle and a knife. The Starflash is head and shoulders above tin foil or your mess kit. It could be the difference in being seen or not.
Also, you might want to reconsider the paracord hanging around your neck. If you don't have a break point built into it.
1. It can be used as a weapon against you. (Think garrot).
2. A nasty slide down a bank could have the paracord get caught on a branch or limb and you'd wind up getting strangled or a broken neck.
Sam, based on this post your grade just dropped to a "D". Since you don't wish to mention your age you are either very young or just immature. Why would you try to debate experts when it's obvious you know way less than them? You've also failed to answer my earlier question. I think we can conclude that you are really just "blowing smoke". Nice try, have a good life. Oh, & your line "Survival is my life" is just plain silly. Do you know why?:cool2:Quote:
Originally Posted by samfranklin
Um, I've got a question, or maybe a comment.
The last I knew, the second "E" in SERE stood for escape. Didn't your SERE instructor teach you that?
Sarge, I gotta disagree with you on that comment. I think he was inhailing...Quote:
Originally Posted by Sarge47
Yes CT, so for Sam's edification, "SERE" = Survival, Evasion, Resistance, and Escape...
Grey Wolf I am in the Uk and in the Uk we have SURVIVE EVADE RESIST EXTRACT
In america it is what you put,
Also
I am young and I do not want to disclose my age over the internet and that is my right.
Sarge 47 you think it is silly because you think that survival is not my life
Sam - In your introduction you stated that you had attended the RN SERE course. With my background, I knew that you meant Royal Navy - maybe not everybody picked up on that. It is important to remember that an open forum has members from around the globe. This, in my opinion is why introductions are important. I completely understand why somebody might not want to reveal too much information in an open forum, and by all means, do not post anything that you are uncomfortable posting. Please realize that members probably range in age from twelve years old to folks in their eighties. We recently had a member that was passing himself off as some sort of expert. He had his own survival website or blog. Much of the information he was passing along might cause harm to those that did not have the experience to know the difference. When folks ask you questions like age, it's just to get a point of reference. Without that point of reference the answers that are given will most likely be from the point of reference from the person answering the question, which may prove to be incorrect or useless to the original poster.
1st, it's obvious that you are very young as well as immature, your posts show that.Quote:
Originally Posted by samfranklin
2nd, Of course "Survival is your life"; DUH! Survival is "Life or Death"!
However, your answers have damaged your credibility. Here's the thing you need to know:
1.) On this forum we have both current & former SERE instructors! We also have many ex-military that have gone through both SERE training & more crap than you could ever imagine; a wise person would be learning from them, not trying to act like they already know everything; which you don't as you never have answered my original question. Remember the old saying: "You can't tell a fool anything, (because they think that they already know everything.) but a word to the wise is sufficient. (A wise person listens & learns from all around them, especially those with more knowledge.)
2.) Too many people try to separate Survival from everything else & make it a separate thing....it's not! It's simply an extension of what ever you may be going through at the moment. When you treat it like you are now you are making it into some sort of game, which is wrong.
Also your answers demonstrate that you don't have a clue as to what I've asked you earlier. Good luck with whatever you're doing.:cool2:
Okay Sarge.... As usual I'm clueless. Read the thread. I see several things missing BUT.... I'm still a very novice novice. I'm interested what is missing PM me if you want. I am finding I have a HUGE amount to learn. I'm so glad I found this site you,ken, crash and everyone are a great help i am thankful to all of you for anything you can tell me. I'll take all the help I can get I NEED IT!!Quote:
Originally Posted by Sarge47
Ok I am 12 and got on the SERE course through connections,
I am taking your advice into account and I am not ingnoring it but I am just making principles and points I have been told. I am not ignoring you I am just expressing what i have been taught
Mk 9 Ration Tin
I have no idea what this is. A picture would help.
Cotton Wool isine ziploc bag
Good fire starter. You can improve it by soaking it in Vaseline. I'm not certain how big Cotton Wool is in the UK but here in the States you can get six of the 100% cotton balls in a 35 mm film canister. Not quite as messing that way. It can also serve as a first aid device because the Vaseline can be used on things like chapped lips and to make a temporary waterproofer for something like a hole in your tent ... if you have nothing else.
MRI GQ 1604 Victorinox Knife (Tie paracord round the top keyring to put round your neck)
I have no idea what this is, either. A pic would help here, too. Never tie any type of cordage around your neck. If you want to carry it that way ensure you have a point where it will easily break or use a chain designed for that purpose.
Calorie Sweets
Don't know what this is.
4 oxo cubes
This is okay if that's what you want. I carry bouillon cubes as well. Just remember, they require water. Otherwise, they are fine.
Candle
Good.
Snare Wire
What kind of wire are you using?
Sheet of Tin foil
Good.
Commando Saw (wire saw)
Throw it away. A wire saw will probably break the first time you use it. Buy a sports folding sports saw. Gerber makes a good ones. There are a lot on the market.
Needle and thread
Good. Make sure the needle is large enough to use on things like packs should you need to. A small assortment of needles is good. You can also replace the thread with fishing line or you can use the inside threads from paracord.
Silva folding compass
Excellent. Have a back up as well.
Beverage pack including sugar tea coffee salt etc.
Good
Wooden handcrafted spear (point for digging holes
Okay. I wouldn't carry a spear. I'd make one if I absolutely needed it. I think a walking stick would serve you better.
Tampon in plastic package
Good
Flint and steel
Good
Hexiblocks
I don't use hexamine. You have to wash your hands after handling it. It smokes and it stinks. Esbit is a lot easier to use and a lot safer.
MK 9 Porrigde bar
I don't know what this is. Is it anything like Stoats Porridge bar?
There's my 2 cents.
Thanks for your comments rick I will get some pictures asap
Cheers
Hi Everybody please note with the paracord round the neck I only use that when sat at my camp when travelling it fits in my tin
Sorry my connection isn't fast enough i will get up soon but for now will slowly do descriptions
Mk 9 Ration Tin
5.5 inches by 3.5 inches by 3 inches so 5.5 inches by 3.5 inches with 3 inches down.
Cotton Wool inside ziploc bag
Cotton wool inside a airtight and water tight plastic bag
MRI GQ 1604 Victorinox Knife
Victorinox brilliant knife and I only wear it round my neck when by my camp never when travelling.
Calorie Sweets
Boiled sweets that contain excessive calories to give you the needed calories.
4 oxo cubes
Candle
Snare Wire
Brass Type
Sheet of Tin foil
Commando Saw (wire saw)
This is the UK standard issue and works well enough I have cut some large pieces of wood with this and it is ok (does the job ok)
Silva folding compass
Beverage pack including sugar tea coffee salt etc.
Wooden handcrafted spear (point for digging holes
It is only a tiny spear about 5 inches long.
Tampon in plastic package
Flint and steel
Hexiblocks
These are just firlighters in hexiblock shape
MK 9 Porrigde bar
mixed with water and sugar to make a horrible porridge type thing!
Hope that answers your questions!
SamF.;(NOTE: If you & I were face-to-face you would here me speaking in a calm voice, not "mean".) I figured you were 12 -13 based on your posts, & now that I understand that I also understand why your comments are immature. Note, I do not say that to be mean, just stating an obvious fact. You seem to think that because you went through a SERE course you got everything you need to survive, but your wrong. Both you & OldSoldier (?) need to understand what is missing in your kits is not an item, but an attitude! That attitude is what OldSoldier has just displayed: He's here to listen & learn! He gets an "A"! Nobody here is telling you anything wrong! They're right on!
Pay attention & learn! That's the 1st step. I'm blunt & to the point! Nicey nice doesn't cut it & there may not be enough time to get to where you need to be if we're all tip-toeing around on egg-shells...which I don't do...just ask anybody!:cool2:
Nope. I don't think you've ever tip-toed on egg shells, Sarge. You're probably the guy who invented scrambled eggs. :innocent: