Which survival manual do you recommend and why?
Printable View
Which survival manual do you recommend and why?
I haven't read them all.:bawling: So I have to say FM21-76. It covers a bit of everything. BUT!! I really like Cody's 98.6, too.
What about Survive by Les Stroud?
Not on the list.
red lake, I knew I was forgetting something *DOH*
I guess that could go under "other"
So, what do you prefer about Survive as opposed to the other books on the list?
I am an avid reader of everything and anything I can get my hands on (which the exception of those cheesy Harlequin novels, blah)...I have read most of the ones listed but am certainly curious what else is out there. Thanks for the recommendation!
I added it for you. If you want it deleted just let me know.
Thanks, Rick!
The Pocket Survival Guide by J. Wayne Fears. No more info than any other guide, but I like how the information is presented. Easy to read and comprehend. As an added bonus the book was dedicated to search and rescue professionals and volunteers. He is one himself.
for the north east i would recomend Ramond mears' The wilderness survival hand book.For the southwest i would recomend a book called Bushcraft. for the rain forest or other? havent found a book
What? No Bear Grylls book? lol
I voted 98.6 Degrees, because it is the only book I have.
tennecedars, when I did an Amazon search for the book, 2 turned up: The Pocket Survival Guide (2004) & The Pocket Outdoor Survival Guide (2006). What is the difference between the two and which do you recommend?
erunkiswldrnssurvival, I wasn't able to find The Wilderness Survival Handbook by Raymond Mears...any links?
The Pocket Survival Guide ISBN 0-88317-305-0
He also wrote The Complete Book Of Outdoor Survival. It's more in depth and a good read.
MM send me a PM and I'll mail you a copy of the pocket guide. I have 2 of em. Keep it or share it when you're done with it.
the pocket survival guide is a good book, i use the bushcraft book often too. the fishing and stone working chapters are informative and accurate.
i liked the outdoor survival handbook by ray mears, but overall i'd say check out every one you can, to the extent that you are interested.
While I haven't read all of the books on the list, I would say read them all. We can always glean bits here and there from different sources. Before too long we have amassed quite a good base of knowledge.
I have them all but I refer to 98.6 the most and use it to teach classes as well
A Bear Grylls book would be titled "Hey, Look at ME"
lmao
Any of y'all that vote "other", please comment on which book you would be referring to....my amazon list is getting pretty long, but there are never enough books in my personal library
Mountain Mama - one of the "other" books I like is Back To Basics A Complete Guide To Traditional Skills I did get it from Amazon. It's not really what most would consider a survival book, but to me it is. With sections titled:
Land: Buying it - Building on it
Energy From Wood, Water, Wind, and Sun
Raising Your Own Vegetables, Fruit and Livestock
Enjoying Your Harvest The Year Round
Skills and Crafts for House and Homestead
While I voted for Cody's Book, I also have both the "Fears" books mentioned here & have even quoted some Survival stories from the larger one that are posted on my Blog. (Cost me about 10 bucks with the S & H from Amazon.) Mors Kochanski put out "Bushcraft", which I also own. (He also authors some great little "pocket" Survival books.) Then there's also the Tom Brown books that some on this site seem to like.Quote:
Originally Posted by tennecedar
I have one Book that's very comprehensive Titled: "The Extreme Survival Almanac: Everything You Need To Know To Live Through a Shipwreck, Plane Crash, Or Any Outdoor Crisis Imanginable." by Reid Kincaid; Who, when the book was published, was the physcian assistant at the Metlakatla Indian Reservation Clinic, not to mention his other credits. (It's put out by Paladin Press.) And of course there's my all time favorite, the Boy Scout Handbook partnered with the Companion Fieldbook. (Older copies.):cool2:
I've read the SAS Survival Handbook which was my first survival book, and thumbed through a couple others which seemed to cover basically the same things. I've also got tom browns field guide to wilderness survival, once again covered a bunch of the same stuff, but also had some extra not really survival info but general living in the wilderness. That caught my attention a bit more than the basic water,fire,shelter,food info, so I bought his field guide to living with the earth which stepped further away from survival and more into living in the wilderness indefinitely. I was going to pick up Survive by les stroud, but unfortunately my income kinda stopped and that's been put on hold for a bit.
Couple of classics you forgot:
"Tom Brown's Field Guide to Wilderness Survival"
and
"At Home in the Wilderness" by Sun Bear
I've basically memorized both of those (got them in my teens) and haven't bothered picking up any newer books on survival since then. I may have to look into a couple of these other ones though. I have heard this Ray Mears guy mentioned a few times recently...might have to get his and Les Strouds.
Also, mandatory reading...A field guide to edible plants, and the Weather Identification handbook....those two books have helped me out alot
Hmm, none, I really don't learn stuff by reading. Don't know why, I suppose it is genetic. I prefer my dad(or similar) telling me "this is the best way in this situation, NOT LIKE THAT YOU IDIOT!", then trying it out and then getting the hang of it.
Jason, you beat me to it. IMO, my two faves are 98.6 and Tom Brown's Field Guide to Wilderness Survival.
Tom also has a sieres of field guide books on tracking, plants, and urban survival, among others.
Bear grylls actually does have a book out. Although I wouldn't doubt that it is ghost written.
"Deep Survival: Who Lives, Who Dies an Why." A good and necessary read. IMHO (The psychology of survival is most inportant)
My second choice would be "Survive" by Les Stroud (as a second step for newcomers) IMHO...
Edit: I really think that "Deep Survival: Who Lives, Who Dies an Why." should be one of the choices.
98.6 is the best I've read or looked at. I've browsed a few at bookstores but don't remember titles.
These two are both excellent, but not my favorite because:
SAS: too much info and really shows a military heritage
Army Field Manual: a little outdated now
I've looked at a PDF version of a really good Australian Army (I think) survival guide that has some fresh stuff other books do not have.
After reading posts, I now must have Les Stroud's book.
I can just picture Bear's book:
Chapter 1: Never Walk Around An Obstacle (Climb and Rappel Your Way to a Short Survival Situation)
Chapter 2: Oh, And Bring a Rope
Chapter 3: Blast! Get Diarreah First
Chapter 4: Hypothermia Tips: Jump Into Freezing Water Naked
Chapter 5: Eat the Nuts (No, Not Those Nuts, Gonads)
Chapter 5: Bring A Crew To Save You From Yourself
You forgot a few:Quote:
Originally Posted by Obsidian
Chapter 6: The art of squeezing water out of elephant poo.
Chapter 7: Drinking Pee.
Chapter 9: Exercises to do naked in the snow.
Chapter 10: the field guide to the best Inns.
Chapter 11: How to sell a $20 knife for $700.
Did I leave anything out?
Yes:
1) have someone tie a rabbit to a post, so you can throw your stick as many times as you need, to hit it!
2) have someone kill a mountain goat and leave it for you, so you don't die in the ice covered mountains.
3) have someone kill a camel and leave it for you, so you don't die in the desert.
I COULD GO ON!
The version of the Army survival manual I read (online) was written around 1940. Have they updated it since?
It would say things like "run your water through a coffee filter for safe drinkable water." Ha ha ha ha haha hahahahaha! Bacteria goes through a coffee filter like a golf ball through a barn door.
Not if I'm swinging the club.......:blushing:Quote:
Originally Posted by bulrush
Yep! There is a May 2002 version for sure.Quote:
Originally Posted by Bulrush
...and think about the 1940's publication. I'll bet there was a whole lot more drinking out of creeks, rivers and ponds back then. Of course there was probably a whole lot more death from waterborne parasites and bacteria as well.
So I was checking out the 1999 "Multiservice Survival Manual" and found one thing I disagree with:
p. VIII-7: Avoid these plants: "(e) Bulbs: ONLY onions smell like onions".
Not true. Wild chives and leeks smell like onions, but those are edible also.
And on same page of plants to avoid, I agree with this:
"(g) Beans, bulbs, or seeds inside pods"
Not all wild peas are edible I found out.
Also, please note while reading these manuals that "filtered" water is not drinkable, but "purified" water is. Filtered water merely gets rid of the chunky chunks, but does nothing for the bacteria. The purification step is what renders bacteria, virii, or cysts harmless.
I wonder how many people will get injured or die copying the idiotic stuff he does. It's really a disservice.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sarge47
And how come Cody doesn't get a show of his own? I can see such a show being absolutely entertaining and darned informative.
I don't know Cody, but I'll bet he wouldn't put up with all the BS that is involved with producing a tv show.
Have a look at
The Survival Handbook By Collin Towell
Brilliant book i have met collin and he is amazing
I forgot one. It's not classified as a survival book, but there's a lot of info in it on finding water in a desert and how the desert is the story of water. Besides, it a darn good read and one of my favorites:
The Secret Knowledge of Water by Craig Childs.
Bajk228.5чтенPREFraumПушкFrieLiviХараEnidИллюМалиТамоSkarAzur
ТараNX04архиDolcПолупотевыпуPensRoseChriДуроГалиФорблириXIII
BlueВПопАлянRemiLoveMPEGперсвечеFranАкулзатрRichAtriSheeFoun
ArthЩеглPushAmarVoguШевцComeJouiYogaIrisанглХентUltrMurpVent
BeliSelawwweнапрKaurAndeИванTrasElleHyunзаниPaliистоEtheAdio
учитZoneденеElegZoneRondCalvчастПришКаваDonaучасХинкMarkGlob
Arts*ыбкредаMiyoинстЛистБалаZoneLAPIZoneZoneменя*еймZoneZone
ZoneZoneзакаZoneZoneКорыБолочистZoneZoneZoneнепрJeweмесястро
JackBekoCataжелтFASBBreaПироGottGlam6110день3896СухоJustМета
JereпьянAmbiСомеMARAраскАгарBaseГонклюдеQwerTeacWindмышлVale
ChouEuphИндиСереЛит*ЩербзолоТрофЦыгаЛит*Лит*FantЛит*унивИван
АльпКоло(193ВелислужТосоNikoНикоАбалWhisЛЕНКдокуLostЛаврScot
ComeПулярабоПисамногМароручеЗайцКесаКороШендInteпамяДудоСвет
СлавмотоСергДемьСазоСнарBodoХотеСимоФедомесямесямесяПолиМигу
MGMTуровJeweвозрВойнМоротуриКорнродиМироtuchkasНики*ыжо