Originally Posted by
JPGreco
If I understand you correctly, you're concerned only with finishing, meaning you can get the shape you want no problem. Like others said, its just a process. I actually just learned about the mineral oil/water trick in this thread. However, I did know that you basically want to work your way up to the highest grits.
I haven't made a knife, but generally, when I install oak hand rails, I only sand down to 180g, 220g if its being finicky. That gets it smooth enough and allows for the stain to run a little truer to color (extensive sanding with high grits will cause stained wood to be a lighter shade vs lower grit sanded wood). Its like painting, you need some rough for the stain to get into and hold on to, more surface area = deeper color with stain. Also, sand with the grain for the most part. Sanding against the grain can remove more stock with coarse grits, but usually also leaves scratches. Even sanding against the grain with a fine grit will leave scratches. Sanding with the grain leaves a smoother finish.